Journal or Magazine? Here’s How To Tell…

 

Scholarly Journal

General Nursing Magazines a.k.a.Trade

Publication

Popular Magazine

Appearance

Articles are research oriented.

Few Pictures.

Illustrations take the form of charts and graphs.

Few Ads

Articles are news oriented; cover trends in the field, etc.

Some illustrations are included, usually charts, graphs, etc.

Trade specific ads.

Articles are meant to inform and entertain.

Illustrations are numerous and colorful.

Lots of advertising.

Audience

Written for experts, researchers, other scholars

Written for professionals within the field or industry (education, business, etc.)

Written for a popular/general audience, or in some cases, an educated layperson

Authors

Scholars and researchers. Authors’ credentials are included

Staff writers or contributing authors. Some articles may be anonymous.

Journalists, staff writers, or contributing authors. Some articles may not be credited.

Bibliography

Authors cite their sources in endnotes, footnotes, or bibliographies. Often includes an abstract.

Authors often mention sources, but rarely formally cite them in bibliographies.

Articles almost never have bibliographies.

Accountability

Articles are peer-reviewed

No peer-review process

No peer-review process

Frequency of Publication

 

Often monthly or even quarterly (every three months).

Usually monthly, although some business newspapers may come out weekly

Often monthly or even weekly (like Time and Newsweek magazines)

Examples

Journal of Nursing Education; Nursing Research; WJNR (Western Journal of Nursing Research)

Adweek; Advertising Age; Chemical and Engineering News; Nursing; RN; Successful Farming

Better Homes and Gardens; Newsweek; Rolling Stone; Time